Skip to content
Humanitarian AIDJAIRI · People first
EN

Second way in · interactive exercise

Review a decision

The case is fictional but built on familiar patterns. Take two minutes to review an automated decision as a responsible person would.

A fictional case for learning; names and figures are invented.

Laila's family — school transport support application

  1. 1The decision
  2. 2What it relied on
  3. 3What was missing?
  4. 4How to review
  5. 5Your request

This decision arrived

System result

Low priority — waiting list: 6 months

Calculated eligibility score: 41 out of 100

Laila applied for transport support for her two children to get to school. An automated system ranked applications by an “eligibility score”, and an official approved the result without changes.

Before you judge: do you know why it received this score?

The information the system relied on

Tap each card to see the source of the information and its date.

  • From last year's declaration, before the father lost his job.

  • From an old record that does not list the grandmother living with them.

  • Measured as a straight line on the map, not by the actual walking route.

  • A medical report was requested by a letter that never reached the family.

  • Counted in a “dependency indicator” that lowers the score.

What did the system miss?Select everything that should have been known before the decision, then press “Check”.

Correct: the system used old income data that does not reflect the family's situation now.

Correct: this is central to the need for transport, and it was in the report whose request never arrived.

Correct: distance on a map does not reflect how dangerous the route is.

Not relevant: not every available piece of information is useful, and collecting it intrudes on privacy for no benefit.

Correct: “incomplete documents” here is a communication failure, not the family's fault.

Not allowed: using nationality or origin to decide eligibility is discrimination and has nothing to do with need.

How would you review the decision?Choose the steps you think are appropriate, then press “Assess my choice”.

Essential: you cannot object to what you do not know.

Effective: the decision was based on old or incomplete data.

Necessary: approving a result as a formality is not human review.

Not appropriate: a system is only as accurate as its data, and its data here are incomplete.

Usually ineffective: it will get the same result and may even count against you.

Important: know the next route before the deadline passes.

Your request is ready

Here is a review request based on your choices. Adapt it to your real situation and do not add sensitive data that is not needed.

Subject: Request for an explanation and human review of the school transport support decision

I kindly request:
1. A written statement of the reasons for the decision and the data used and their source, and confirmation of whether an automated system took part.
2. Correction of the data relied on; I attach evidence of current income and the requested medical report, noting that the letter requesting it never reached me.
3. Referral of the application to an official authorised to amend the decision, for review once the data are corrected.
4. Information on where I can complain and the deadline if the decision remains unchanged.

Attached: [current income] [medical report]
Yours sincerely,
[Name] — [Contact details]

What we learned

  • A system is only as accurate as its data.
  • Approving a result without examining it is not human review.
  • Not every available piece of information is useful or allowed.

1 / 5

Continue from here

Before relying on any tool, ask

  1. Who is affected by the result, and do they know a tool took part?
  2. Which data were used, and are they necessary and correct?
  3. Can an authorised person change the result?
  4. What happens if the tool is wrong, and who bears the cost?

Understand the impact → · Share your experience →

From the DJAIRI ecosystem

Platforms that continue what you start here.

DJAIRI portal (opens another site)